You've got all kinds of bumps going on
! Hands off, no more attempting to pop it, and baby it. It's likely that the tissue is just really pissed off and probably torn from you bumping it, so I'd just baby the hell out of it for awhile (but don't overdo sss or cleaning!). On the other hand, it could very well be hypertrophic scarring that's forming because of the trauma to the piercing and perhaps the movement of jewelry. I personally would do a salt soak or two a day and otherwise leave it alone for a week or two longer, then get advice from your piercer. Also, be sure that whatever you wash your face/ hair with isn't coming into contact with it, and rinse very well after showering/washing your face/whatever.