well - your pics do not seem to be 'that bad' to me - but i really do not know anything about tragus piercings per se...
i have never heard of someone 'accidentally' piercing their tragus, but i guess you did - apparently you have very soft cartilege and there are no pain-sensors there... bummers...
hopefully you are not planning to do anything else to your ear in the next couple of days... as has been mentioned - treat the 'new' hole as a fresh piercing and take really good care of it... now, if you do not like/want to have the two holes in your tragus (or even worse a stretched-between-larger size hole), then i am not sure what to recommend...
personally, i would prolly go to my piercer and have them look it over... once youre both discussing options - you can also discuss the jewelry situation... clearly, there was something wrong with the jewelry choices youve made so far - or maybe it was just your USE of the jewelry... i think someone will need to chat with you in-person and get a feel/see what is happening, so that you/they can discuss the pros/cons of what-how-why you are having issues...
really, you can post more details here - im not trying to discourage you... and im sorry that the long-post youd written got eaten-up by the browser - but try to get to a reputable piercer in person, also, asap... gl, h.
exactly 8.25250000001mm (0g) ear lobes only... so far...
HII method: harold is insane... make sure to read everything i say and follow the most-insane ideas. if youre lucky - you can be insane too. 8-)
standard disclaimer here