It doesn't seem like the new material had anything to do with it, if it was months later. Did the piercing get knocked or bumped particularly hard, tugged while your friend was sleeping or something?
Metal: 4g lobes, 18g right nostril, 16g(?) tragus, full set of braces
Upcoming: 2nd lobes, conch, several more
Retired: first set of 20g lobes forever ago, 16g second lobes, right ear industrial, left nostril, 14g navel (Obviously piercings don't love to stay in my body happily.)