Downsizing will certainly help. If you're willing to make the time commitment, take them out entirely for a month or two and massage them daily (or even twice daily) with vitamin e oil to help reduce any scar tissue you may have formed. You can easily do this while watching tv, which makes it a little less monotonous. Then re-stretch, slowly, with good quality tapers and titanium or glass sf plugs. There is a stretching timeline guide here.
Personally, I think a month is a little excessive to wait. If you've stretched properly (which should not hurt, by the way, you may feel a tightness or some heat but no pain) then you should be fine to wear organics in a week or two. None of these guidelines are set in stone; they're guides and you need to pay attention to what's going on with your ears. Take the organics out once a day and oil them up. If the organics are sticking to your ears or if you're experiencing any discomfort or odd feelings, remove them for glass or titanium/steel. Be careful with cheaper economy steel plugs, they contain nickel which a large percentage of people are sensitive to; if you experience swelling, itching, soreness, redness, or weeping while wearing steel, switch it out for glass or titanium.
Good luck.
Morally bankrupt unnatural heathen.
3/4" lobes
7mm inner conch
8mm scalpelled outer conch/helix
4g septum